My wife and I went on this tour during our 3-week vacation across Europe. Over the course of the 3 weeks, we went on about 8-10 tours. All of them, except for this one, were both extremely informative and thoughtful. Unfortunately, this one was pretty underwhelming.
Our tour guide spent a lot of time making jokes and talking about herself. At first, it was funny and engaging; however, after it continued throughout the tour, it felt like she was practicing a stand-up comedy routine. Don’t get me wrong, I love comedy, but when we’re cramming in a short tour of the Vatican Museum, which is HUGE, I’d like to learn as much as possible. Also, some of her jokes came off as though she had PTSD from going to Catholic school growing up. I’m sure this would make for a great comedy skit, but given the Vatican is probably the most holy place for the Catholic Church, this probably isn’t the right venue for that.
Also, the information quality of the tour was pretty high level. We learned the basics of the art, but our tour guide did not appear to be an expert or highly knowledgeable. We ended up leaving the tour early, and we're happy we did because the rest of the tour group missed The School of Athens, which is probably one of the museum's most famous pieces of artwork.
All that said, to be fair, I do think some people would enjoy this tour. If you’re primarily interested in quickly checking out the Vatican Museum and would be happy if you see a few of the major highlights and learn a thing or two, then this tour is probably great.
However, if you’d like an expert guide who has a deep understanding of the art, tries to teach you as much as possible in the short tour, and can answer questions, perhaps another tour would be better. If we were to do it again, we’d rent an audioguide.